(845) 398-1717 susan@ImagineProperties1.com Imagine Properties
    Traffic Dashboard
    Home Home
    • HOME
    • ABOUT
      • Learn More
      • Meet the Team
      • Reviews
    • LIST OF SERVICES
      • Union News
      • Services
    • MORTGAGE
      • Mortgage Calculator
    • COMMUNITIES
      • Areas
      • Community News
      • All Listings
      • Palm Beach County
      • New Jersey
    • IMAGINE HELP
    • BUYERS
      • Buying Tips
      • Featured Listings
      • Search New York Homes
      • Search New Jersey Homes
    • SELLERS
      • Home Valuation
    • INVESTORS
    • RESOURCES
      • Slattery Moving & Storage
      • Short Sale
      • Senior Real Estate
      • Probate
      • Articles
    • MORE
      • Florida
      • School Report
      • Real Estate Tips
      • Sold Properties
    • RITZ-CARLTON RESIDENCES
    • CONTACT
    Traffic Dashboard
    Susan Camus
    (845) 398-1717 susan@ImagineProperties1.com
    • 100 Dutch Hill Rd Suite 260
      Orangeburg, NY 10962
    Home
    • HOME
    • ABOUT
    • LIST OF SERVICES
    • MORTGAGE
    • COMMUNITIES
    • IMAGINE HELP
    • BUYERS
    • SELLERS
    • INVESTORS
    • RESOURCES
    • MORE
    • RITZ-CARLTON RESIDENCES
    • CONTACT
    Legal
    • Privacy
    • Terms
    • DMCA
    • Accessibility
    • Fair Housing
    Account
    • Dashboard
    • Logout
    • Login
    Susan Camus | Imagine Properties - Footer Logo
    ©2026 Imagine Properties. All rights reserved.
    Website built by CloseHack.
    Miami Association of REALTORS®

    MIAMI ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Multiple Listing Service. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Marjo Realty Co. may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS.

    New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc.

    The data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Susan Camus | Imagine Properties are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website. 

    All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: 01/09/2023

    2023 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.  

    My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS

    IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website. Listing Information presented by local MLS brokerage: Susan Camus | Imagine Properties

    OneKey MLS

    IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

    Back

    Rentals in Middletown, NY

    Browse by Listing Type
    attach_moneyFor Sale editFor Rent
    Browse by Property Type
    homeHouses apartmentCondos & Apartments holiday_villageTownhouses & Duplexes crop_landscapeLots & Land parkFarms & Ranches

    MARKET SNAPSHOT

    The Market at a Glance

    How homes have been selling here over the last 90 days.

    home_work New This Week 11
    Went Under Contract 1
    trending_down Price Reductions 0
    payments Median Sale Price $457,500 +24.9%
    square_foot Price per Sq Ft $143
    schedule Avg Days on Market 51
    sell Homes Sold 106
    percent Sale-to-List Ratio 102.0%
    inventory_2 Months of Inventory 6.6

    Price & Sales History

    Market data reflects closed sales over the last 90 days and is provided for informational purposes.

    BROWSE BY ZIP

    Zip Codes

    Browse listings by postal code in this area.

    010 homes for saleMedian sale$295K1 sale in the last 90 days
    003 homes for saleMedian sale$295K
    0001 home for saleMedian sale$295K
    00006 homes for saleMedian sale$295K
    0000029 homes for saleMedian sale$370KPer sq ft$199 sales in the last 90 days
    0060225 homes for saleMedian sale$417.5KPer sq ft$3124 sales in the last 90 days
    0060322 homes for saleMedian sale$235KPer sq ft$7273 sales in the last 90 days
    0061228 homes for saleMedian sale$160KPer sq ft$1685 sales in the last 90 days
    0062359 homes for saleMedian sale$240KPer sq ft$19214 sales in the last 90 days
    006418 homes for saleMedian sale$262KPer sq ft$1762 sales in the last 90 days
    00646141 homes for saleMedian sale$1.5MPer sq ft$59625 sales in the last 90 days
    0066239 homes for saleMedian sale$463KPer sq ft$2939 sales in the last 90 days
    View All Zip Codes
    Get Alerts Advanced Search
    • Grid
    • Map
    • List
    91 North Street #204 For Rent
    $1,700
    91 North Street #204Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 828 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • KEY1039746
    32 Deer Ct Drive For Rent
    $2,700
    32 Deer Ct DriveMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1508 sqft
    • Built 2002
    • KEY1039603
    108 North Street #302 For Rent
    $1,900
    108 North Street #302Middletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 750 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • KEY1040262
    240 Schutt Road #1C For Rent
    $1,625
    240 Schutt Road #1CMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 700 sqft
    • Built 1994
    • KEY1041247
    41 Genung Street #41 For Rent
    $3,100
    41 Genung Street #41Middletown, NY 10940
    • 4 bd
    • 3 ba
    • 2229 sqft
    • Built 2004
    • KEY1014196
    1 Avenue A For Rent
    $3,500
    1 Avenue AMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 4 bd
    • 3.5 ba
    • 2000 sqft
    • Built 2019
    • KEY1040750
    205 Concord Lane For Rent
    $2,000
    205 Concord LaneMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 924 sqft
    • Built 1990
    • 1040842
    39 Crescent Place For Rent
    $2,400
    39 Crescent PlaceMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 1.5 ba
    • 1278 sqft
    • Built 1908
    • 1040022
    8 Green Court For Rent
    $4,200
    8 Green CourtMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2.5 ba
    • 2594 sqft
    • Built 2005
    • 1029009
    240 Schutt Road #3B For Rent
    $1,675
    240 Schutt Road #3BMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 700 sqft
    • Built 1994
    • 1039999
    25 Fairways Drive #5 For Rent
    $2,900
    25 Fairways Drive #5Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2.5 ba
    • 1345 sqft
    • Built 2005
    • 1033817
    20 Benton Avenue For Rent
    $3,000
    20 Benton AvenueMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1504 sqft
    • Built 1913
    • 1037522
    934 Tower Ridge Circle For Rent
    $2,500
    934 Tower Ridge CircleMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1249 sqft
    • Built 2007
    • 1032438
    12 Dundee Circle For Rent
    $4,000
    12 Dundee CircleMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 2144 sqft
    • Built 1975
    • 1036051
    25 Clinton Street For Rent
    $3,650
    25 Clinton StreetMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 3 ba
    • 1902 sqft
    • Built 2002
    • 1036004
    204 Stony Ford Road For Rent
    $3,000
    204 Stony Ford RoadMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 3 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1008 sqft
    • Built 1955
    • 1035668
    48 North Street #307 For Rent
    $3,045
    48 North Street #307Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 861 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034247
    48 North Street #301 For Rent
    $2,950
    48 North Street #301Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 861 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034213
    48 North Street #401 For Rent
    $3,050
    48 North Street #401Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 861 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034220
    48 North Street #407 For Rent
    $3,145
    48 North Street #407Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 811 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034180
    48 North Street #405 For Rent
    $3,125
    48 North Street #405Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 850 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034166
    48 North Street #408 For Rent
    $2,750
    48 North Street #408Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 811 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034156
    48 North Street #305 For Rent
    $3,025
    48 North Street #305Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 850 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034171
    48 North Street #308 For Rent
    $2,700
    48 North Street #308Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 811 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034148
    48 North Street #208 For Rent
    $2,650
    48 North Street #208Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 825 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1034128
    48 North Street #406 For Rent
    $2,525
    48 North Street #406Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 758 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1032738
    43 Broad Street #2 For Rent
    $1,800
    43 Broad Street #2Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 959 sqft
    • Built 1923
    • 1032963
    103 Wickham Avenue #3 For Rent
    $1,900
    103 Wickham Avenue #3Middletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 700 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • 1032135
    226 Concord Lane For Rent
    $1,700
    226 Concord LaneMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 735 sqft
    • Built 1989
    • 1032731
    48 North Street #402 For Rent
    $3,100
    48 North Street #402Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1.5 ba
    • 861 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030448
    202 Midland Lake Road #BARN For Rent
    $1,100
    202 Midland Lake Road #BARNMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 4000 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • 1031474
    48 North Street #306 For Rent
    $2,475
    48 North Street #306Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 766 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1031455
    48 North Street #206 For Rent
    $2,425
    48 North Street #206Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 766 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1031453
    48 North Street #404 For Rent
    $3,145
    48 North Street #404Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 924 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1031451
    48 North Street #304 For Rent
    $3,045
    48 North Street #304Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 924 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030455
    48 North Street #403 For Rent
    $2,450
    48 North Street #403Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 761 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1031447
    48 North Street #303 For Rent
    $2,425
    48 North Street #303Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 761 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1031441
    48 North Street #302 For Rent
    $3,000
    48 North Street #302Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1.5 ba
    • 854 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030451
    109 Lake Avenue For Rent
    $2,500
    109 Lake AvenueMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 922 sqft
    • Built 1923
    • 1027306
    48 North Street #205 For Rent
    $2,450
    48 North Street #205Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 750 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030444
    48 North Street #204 For Rent
    $2,450
    48 North Street #204Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 750 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030441
    48 North Street #207 For Rent
    $2,595
    48 North Street #207Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 852 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030129
    48 North Street #203 For Rent
    $2,195
    48 North Street #203Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 750 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030138
    108 North Street #303 For Rent
    $1,500
    108 North Street #303Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 550 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • 1011023
    48 North Street #201 For Rent
    $2,445
    48 North Street #201Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 750 sqft
    • Built 1938
    • 1030109
    2 Fortune Road W #2B For Rent
    $2,300
    2 Fortune Road W #2BMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1112 sqft
    • Built 1972
    • 1029754
    66 Phillips Street For Rent
    $2,600
    66 Phillips StreetMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 4 bd
    • 1.5 ba
    • 1280 sqft
    • Built 1957
    • 1028125
    60 Peach Place For Rent
    $3,000
    60 Peach PlaceMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 3.5 ba
    • 2041 sqft
    • Built 2001
    • 1028054
    410 Tower Ridge Circle For Rent
    $2,700
    410 Tower Ridge CircleMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1250 sqft
    • Built 2026
    • 1027791
    214 Tower Ridge Circle For Rent
    $3,000
    214 Tower Ridge CircleMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1336 sqft
    • Built 2026
    • 1027775
    30 E Main Street #4 For Rent
    $1,500
    30 E Main Street #4Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 600 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • 965296
    708 Silver Lake Scotchtown Road For Rent
    $2,850
    708 Silver Lake Scotchtown RoadMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1600 sqft
    • Built 1970
    • 1025601
    54 Fairways Drive For Rent
    $3,100
    54 Fairways DriveMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2.5 ba
    • 1795 sqft
    • Built 2008
    • 1024919
    184 Highland Avenue For Rent
    $3,500
    184 Highland AvenueMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1486 sqft
    • Built 1920
    • 941354
    206 Golf Links Road #721 For Rent
    $2,400
    206 Golf Links Road #721Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1142 sqft
    • Built 2025
    • 986905
    31 Pinto Road W For Rent
    $2,700
    31 Pinto Road WMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 2 bd
    • 2.5 ba
    • 1782 sqft
    • Built 2021
    • 1016337
    943 Tower Ridge Circle For Rent
    $2,250
    943 Tower Ridge CircleMiddletown, NY 10941
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 888 sqft
    • Built 2007
    • 1020312
    125 Wickham Avenue #3B For Rent
    $2,000
    125 Wickham Avenue #3BMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 650 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • 1019987
    7 Giada Lane #1 For Rent
    $2,300
    7 Giada Lane #1Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 950 sqft
    • Built 2025
    • 1019860
    748 Greenville Turnpike For Rent
    $3,800
    748 Greenville TurnpikeMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 4 bd
    • 2.5 ba
    • 2620 sqft
    • Built 1920
    • 1017019
    950 Route 17m For Rent
    $2,600
    950 Route 17mMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1928 sqft
    • Built 1932
    • 1013027
    206 Golf Links Road #713 For Rent
    $2,200
    206 Golf Links Road #713Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1.5 ba
    • 1031 sqft
    • Built 2025
    • 974427
    153 Wisner Avenue For Rent
    $2,750
    153 Wisner AvenueMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1466 sqft
    • Built 1933
    • 1011917
    102 North Street #8 For Rent
    $1,690
    102 North Street #8Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 703 sqft
    • Built 1950
    • 1007930
    2 E Main Street #5 For Rent
    $1,850
    2 E Main Street #5Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1200 sqft
    • Built 1954
    • 1005833
    14 Smith Street For Rent
    $3,400
    14 Smith StreetMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1852 sqft
    • Built 1903
    • 1001585
    90 Montgomery Street #Upper For Rent
    $2,300
    90 Montgomery Street #UpperMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 900 sqft
    • Built 1889
    • 1001009
    206 Golf Links Road #825 For Rent
    $2,400
    206 Golf Links Road #825Middletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1142 sqft
    • Built 2024
    • 999472
    1 Ruth Court For Rent
    $2,200
    1 Ruth CourtMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 984 sqft
    • Built 1988
    • 994350
    157 White Bridge Road For Rent
    $2,200
    157 White Bridge RoadMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 2 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1041 sqft
    • Built 1951
    • 995629
    63 Broad Street For Rent
    $2,550
    63 Broad StreetMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 1088 sqft
    • Built 1870
    • 971927
    52 Horton Avenue For Rent
    $3,000
    52 Horton AvenueMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 3 bd
    • 2.5 ba
    • 2340 sqft
    • Built 1960
    • 979192
    225 Monhagen Avenue For Rent
    $3,500
    225 Monhagen AvenueMiddletown, NY 10940
    • 4 bd
    • 2 ba
    • 1466 sqft
    • Built 1972
    • 975345
    23 W Main Street #1 For Rent
    $1,900
    23 W Main Street #1Middletown, NY 10940
    • 1 bd
    • 1 ba
    • 770 sqft
    • Built 1900
    • 971576
    74

    Middletown Searches

    • All Middletown
    • For Sale in Middletown
    • Houses in Middletown
    • Condos & Apartments in Middletown
    • Townhouses & Duplexes in Middletown
    • Lots & Land in Middletown
    • Farms & Ranches in Middletown

    Featured Searches

    Advanced Search
    • $200k to $300k Homes
    • $300k to $400k Homes
    • $400k to $500k Homes
    • Acreage
    • Commercial Properties
    • Farms & Ranches
    • Golf Course Homes
    • Homes Listed this Week
    • Homes with 2+ Beds
    • Homes with Pools
    • Large Houses (2k+ sqft)
    • Luxury Condos ($400k+)
    • Multi-Family Homes
    • New Construction
    • Oceanfront Condos
    • Rentals Under $2k
    • Rentals with Pets
    • Under $200k Homes
    • Under $250k Homes
    • Water View Homes
    • Water View Homes

    Popular Cities

    All Cities
    • Miami8657 Listings
    • Orlando5530 Listings
    • ocala4757 Listings
    • Port Charlotte4756 Listings
    • Tampa4503 Listings
    • Kissimmee3841 Listings
    • Sarasota3472 Listings
    • North Port3050 Listings
    • St Petersburg2915 Listings
    • Port St. Lucie2758 Listings

    Recent Articles

    All Articles
    • The Best Real Estate Agent in Manatee, Florida: Prime Ibarrientos at Susan Camus | Imagine Properties
    • Luxury Waterfront Homes with Private Docks for Sale in Manatee, Florida - Your Gateway to Exclusive Coastal Living
    • Retirement Communities in Manatee, Florida: Embrace an Active Lifestyle at Susan Camus | Imagine Properties
    • Family-Friendly Enclaves in Manatee, Florida: Unveiling Top-Rated School Districts and Neighborhood Gems
    • The Top Real Estate Agent in Bergen, New York: Prime Ibarrientos at Susan Camus | Imagine Properties
    • Luxurious Waterfront Homes with Private Docks for Sale in Bergen, New York: The Ultimate Guide
    • Exploring the Best Retirement Communities in Bergen, New York: Embrace an Active Lifestyle Today
    • Family-Friendly Enclaves and Top-Rated Schools: Unveiling Bergen, New York's Ideal Residential Haven
    • The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Best Real Estate Agent in Rockland, New York
    • Waterfront Homes with Private Dock for Sale in Rockland, New York: A Dreamy Waterfront Living Experience